So… Cat Lady won Scarezone of the Year during the event. It’s announced to casts midway through the last night of the run. Second, the “Of the Year” award is only marginally based on fan opinion. It’s largely based on management and creative opinions, which is impacted by cast activity itself. So, that doesn’t count.
Cat Lady (and of a similar account, Scarecrow) also have nothing to do with Pumpkin Lord. At all. Universal already has their own Samhain character from The Hallow (2008), and they’ve done numerous “classic Halloween” themed things. They’ve done those things without Pumpkin Lord, which means he’s not “required.”
I really just wish fans were less interested in seeing the same characters and themes over and over, and instead ask for new things.